As the World Cup reaches its final stages(yes, as I’m writing this Spain has a 2-0 lead over France…WOW), the familiar debate has returned: What separates a truly great player from a truly great team?
That question sits at the heart of the opening chapter of Surrender to Lead. I wrote about Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo because they represent two profoundly different approaches to achievement: control versus surrender, individual force versus collective trust.
The following is adapted directly from the book.
Eight minutes into stoppage time in the 2022 World Cup soccer quarterfinals, Cristiano Ronaldo locked eyes with his teammate and stabbed his finger toward an open space on the pitch, his teeth clenched and his body tense. One last urgent command. One final attempt to seize control before it slipped away for good.
Down by a single goal to Morocco, Ronaldo’s Portuguese national team threw everything forward in a desperate push for an equalizer, while the Moroccan bench—in a blur of frantic gestures—implored the referee to end the match. The ball moved in the other direction, out from Ronaldo’s reach and away from his control. He sprinted forward, but before he could make his move, the referee’s whistle pierced the air.
The game was over.
This wasn’t just another World Cup. It had been billed as the final showdown between Ronaldo and Argentina’s Lionel Messi—the culmination of a decades- long debate. For years, fans had argued passionately over who was the GOAT (the greatest footballer of all time): Ronaldo, with his staggering career goal count, physical dominance, and relentless drive, or Messi, who was smaller, quieter, and often in Ronaldo’s statistical shadow yet unmatched in assists and as a builder of team cohesion. Neither had won a World Cup, and a victory in this tournament would be seen by many as the defining accolade. In the end, they never even got to face each other.
As Ronaldo walked off, shattered, the contrast had never been clearer.
Ronaldo knew, as did the rest of the world watching, that this was likely his last chance at winning a World Cup. This one crowning achievement, the one glaring absence in his decorated career that had always been just out of reach, had slipped away for good. That’s what made what happened next so hard to watch.
His gait slowed, his eyes dropped to the ground, his jaw clenched, and he walked—not toward his teammates but straight for the tunnel. When he finally did look up, you could see his lips were pursed tight, as if holding something in—his emotion in that moment, perhaps.
A Moroccan player wrapped his arm around Ronaldo’s shoulder and reached out for a handshake. Ronaldo extended his hand and nodded as if on autopilot. For a second, it looked normal, a standard postmatch embrace, but his emotions betrayed him. His body stiffened, caught between two versions of himself—the Ronaldo the world expected to see and the Ronaldo who could no longer hold it together.
For a fleeting second, he was still in control. The handshake, the nod, the composed exterior—it was all instinct, years of conditioning forcing him to maintain the image of a man unfazed. But beneath that carefully maintained surface, something was breaking. He had spent his entire career mastering control—of his body, of his image, of the game itself. But now, at this moment, he didn’t know how to lose control. And he didn’t want to.
He pulled away, subtly but firmly freeing himself from the first embrace. But before he could escape entirely, another Moroccan player approached. This time, Ronaldo had to speak. He muttered something—just a few words, but enough to make it clear: Leave me alone.
And that’s when it happened. The momentary effort of forming words, of acknowledging reality, was enough to crack the thin layer of composure he had left. His voice betrayed him, and if you watch that moment closely, that is when he begins to cry.
He did not look at his teammates. He did not acknowledge the Portuguese fans still watching in stunned silence. He barely seemed to notice when a fan ran into him before getting tackled by a bodyguard. He stayed laser- focused on the dark tunnel ahead of him—his escape from the chaos of the field. When he finally reached the darkness, he fell apart. You can see him let go the second his body is in the shadow of the tunnel.
For two decades, Ronaldo had commanded the field, the cameras, the world’s attention. His presence was larger than life, his control absolute—every moment calculated. But now, as he stepped into the tunnel, he wasn’t just leaving the pitch; he was leaving his lifelong dream behind. It was the end of an era for Ronaldo. He had clung to the belief that if he just did more, he could force the outcome he wanted. But when the final whistle blew, the weight of that belief came crashing down. The trut was undeniable: Effort alone hadn’t been enough. His strategy, the one that had defined his entire career, had reached its limit.
Eight days later, Messi stood on a podium in the center of the same pitch, a triumphant smile illuminating his face, as he lifted the World Cup trophy—his dream finally realized. Today, Messi is the most decorated player in the history of professional soccer, having won six Golden Boots, forty- five team trophies (including twelve Big Five league titles), four UEFA Champions Leagues, two Copa Americas, and—most importantly—one FIFA World Cup.
The contrast with Ronaldo couldn’t have been sharper.
For Ronaldo, winning had always been about his personal effort in creating results. “I’ve never seen anyone better than me. I have always thought that,” he once declared. “There’s no player more complete than me. I play well with both feet. I’m quick, powerful, good with the head. I score goals. I make assists.”
But unlike Ronaldo, Messi’s pursuit had never been about personal accolades or chasing the title of the greatest. He didn’t win by controlling every detail, dictating every move, or forcing the game to bend to his will. He won by letting go—trusting his team, playing within the flow of the game, and surrendering the need for personal validation.
“It doesn’t change anything for me to be the best or not,” Messi had said just a year earlier. “And I never tried to be, either.” Instead of fixating on proving his superiority, Messi focused on the game itself, on moving the ball, on making his teammates better. “When you look at which sides earn success in football, it is always those who work together as a group, who fight for each other—and every single member holds value and importance.”
His career was not built on force but on flow—an unwavering belief that the greatest success isn’t something you can force but is something you create with others. And now, with his teammates surrounding him, lifting him on their shoulders, the world could see the truth clearly: Messi’s surrender to the team, his belief of the strength of all above any one person, had brought the ultimate reward.
Messi’s approach wasn’t just philosophical—it showed up in the numbers. He played for the team. Messi had 381 career assists, compared to Ronaldo’s 257. He made more key passes, created more scoring chances, and facilitated more goals for those around him. Meanwhile, Ronaldo scored 927 career goals but needed 182 more games than Messi to reach that total. Ronaldo was more dominant individually, but Messi’s impact on his team’s overall success was greater.
What differentiated these two legendary athletes wasn’t just skill—it was their entire approach to success. Messi trusted the game, the team, and the process. Ronaldo fought it. And in the moment that mattered most, that fight consumed him.
Ronaldo was trapped in a faulty belief that if he just controlled his teammates and the flow of the game, he would win. When the final whistle blew, the weight of that belief came crashing down. The game had moved on. Time had moved on. And he was still clinging to air, unable to change what had already slipped away.
Ronaldo was caught in what we call the Action Trap—the all- too- common belief that if you simply push harder, control more, and demand more, you will eventually get the result you want. But as he eventually discovered, the more you try to control everything, and everyone, the more they end up controlling you.
But true greatness isn’t about controlling every play. It’s about elevating those around you. Just ask the GOAT—Messi.
Elsewhere In Culture
What Cruise Ships Reveal About Workplace Culture with John Frehse
John joined me to unpack what a week at sea taught me about compensation, fairness, and the assumptions we make about the people serving us. We talked about employees working every day for six months, the enormous differences in pay and living conditions onboard, and why workplace inequity becomes much harder to ignore when everyone is stuck on the same boat. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ceo-daily-brief-with-dr-jessica-kriegel/id1725350421?i=1000776571897 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/1pVLWPwNFYYI1urNFARsd5?si=85db60e1a2844eb7
The Positive Consequences of AI with John Frehse
John and I explored how AI is breaking the long-standing connection between hours worked and productivity. He shared how one data scientist turned six hours of complicated client conversations into two slides that delivered exactly the right message, and we asked what leaders should do with all the time AI is giving people back. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ceo-daily-brief-with-dr-jessica-kriegel/id1725350421?i=1000776737214 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/5cKppJVUGKXVIR9erGFuyV?si=5d660509e6804069
Why Being in the Room Matters with Mary Daffin
I sat down with Mary Daffin to talk about why physical community matters more in an increasingly digital world. We explored how AI is making everyone look better on paper, why face-to-face interaction has become the real differentiator, and what can happen when you intentionally bring the right people into the same room. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ceo-daily-brief-with-dr-jessica-kriegel/id1725350421?i=1000776886129 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/3FXpBI5o0o2Z2l670YT4v8?si=c26eec07747b4faf
And coming later this week…
Fighting on LinkedIn
I recently found myself in an argument on LinkedIn and had to decide whether to defend myself, fight back, or respond differently. I unpack the exchange and what it taught me about conflict, accountability, and why leadership sometimes means choosing to be the person who shifts the relationship first.
Does Success Help or Hurt You? with John Frehse
John and I explored whether success can make leaders less curious, less empirical, and more likely to trust their own instincts without questioning them. We talked about the difference between grounded intuition and ego-driven certainty, especially as AI makes it easier to put leadership decisions on cruise control.